Synapses are highly specialized sites of asymmetric cell–cell contact that mediate information transfer between neurons. Many proteins have been identified that contribute to the complex processes that underlie the formation, organization, and maintenance of synapses, and the molecular biology of synapse formation is increasingly well understood. Surprisingly, synaptic differentiation does not require a cellular target. Hemisynaptic specializations form quickly at sites of neurite adhesion to microspheres coated with a synaptogenic protein or a synthetic cationic polypeptide like polylysine. This raises the possibility that functional hemisynaptic connections could be directed to form onto engineered surfaces; however, studies examining the stability of synaptic specializations formed in the brain onto polylysine-coated beads found that they were unstable and degraded within a few weeks after implantation. Here, we demonstrate that microbeads coated with dendritic polyglycerol amine (dPGA), a nonprotein macromolecular biomimetic of polylysine, promote enhanced synaptogenesis and synapse stability compared to conventional polylysine. We show that a dPGA coating is stable in long-term cell culture, resisting proteolysis, and that dPGA-coated beads cluster neurexin, which is sufficient to direct presynaptic terminal formation. We propose that synthetic synaptogenic extracellular matrices that resist proteolysis could be used to engineer electrodes with enhanced neural biocompatibility and support long-term bidirectional communication with neurons by directing the formation of stable synaptic specializations.