Regulation of cartilage differentiation

Regulation of cartilage differentiation


Our hand skeleton develops in a series of interconnected developmental steps that lead from the initial emergence of cartilaginous condensations in the autopod to their expansion and elongation and their segmentation by joints. These events are orchestrated by a complex regulatory network that assures the correct positioning and growth of the skeletal elements. Disturbances in this network, caused for example by gene mutation, results in hand malformation syndromes. 

The figure shows the formation, elongation and segmentation of the digits in the mouse forelimb. Left panel: whole-mount in-situ hybridization with probes showing precartilaginous condensations (Sox9), cartilage condensations (Col2a1) and joint interzones (Gdf5). Right panel: skeletal preparation of a newborn mouse hand. Digits 1-5 are indicated, m=metacarpal, p1-p3=phalanges 1-3. From Stricker and Mundlos, Developmental Dynamics 2011, 240(5), 990-1004.

To elucidate the genetic mechanisms of digit formation and elongation we analyze a group of human hand malformations, the brachydactylies (Greek, brachys=short, dactylos=finger) as well as other inheritable conditions. The identification of disease-causing mutations in these syndromes provided a wealth of information, which is further analyzed in different experimental setups. We are mainly interested in analyzing the pathomechanism that leads to malformation using animal models.

Genetics of Digit Elongation

In our analysis we focus on the most severe form of the brachydactylies, brachydactyly type B1. BDB1 is characterized by shortening/hypoplasia/aplasia of the distal phalanges, is caused by mutations in ROR2, encoding a receptor tyrosine kinase. BDB mutations in ROR2 truncate the protein either immediately in front of or after the tyrosine kinase domain leading to the expression of truncated proteins. In contrast, missense or nonsense mutations leading to amino acid exchange or truncation of extracellular domains of ROR2, truncation within the TK domain, or selective inactivation of TK activity lead to autosomal recessive Robinow syndrome (RRS).

Mutations in ROR2 cause BDB (left) and recessive RS (right). Mutations in BDB lead to the expression of truncated proteins while RS mutations most likely lead to a loss of function of the protein.

Mutations causing RRS are most likely associated with a loss of function of the protein, since they show retention in the endoplasmatic reticulum, while BDB mutations that localize to the plasma membrane likely interfere with signaling at the cell surface (Schwarzer et al. 2009). 

Surface localization of BDB1 mutant, intracellular retention of RRS mutant form of ROR2. Modified from Schwarzer et al. 2009

Pathomechanism of BDB: In collaboration with Aris N. Econimides (Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Tarrytown, USA) we have analyzed a knock-in mouse mutant harboring an exact copy of a human BDB mutation (Ror2-W745X, Raz et al. 2008). The mutant exhibited a brachydactyly phenotype with missing medial phalanges. The analysis of the mutant phenotype showed a specific impairment of digit elongation during the formation of the phalangeal condensations. This was caused by a disruption of Bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling detected by phosphorylation the major BMP downstream components, the transcription factors SMAD1, 5 and 8. Our results demonstrate that this signaling center is active in mammalian digit elongation and suggest that its failure is causative for human disease (Witte et al. 2010). 

Phenotype of the Ror2-W749X knock-in mouse mutant. Col2a1 WMISH shows a defect in the elongation of the digit anlagen at E13.5. Skeletal preparations of forelimbs from newborn mice, cartilage stains blue, bone stains red. Note the missing medial phalanges in the W749X mutant (arrows). Immunostaining for pSMAD1/5/8 demonstrates the presence of a BMP signaling center distal to the growing cartilage condensation, which is absent in the Ror2-W745X mouse. Modified from Witte et al. 2010

Is there a common pathomechanism for the brachydactylies as a molecular disease family? The brachydactylies are a syndrome family that shares overlapping features. Intriguingly, many of the mutations causing the different brachydactyly subtypes are found in members of the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) pathway (see figure). In addition to that, BDA1 is caused by mutations in Indian hedgehog (IHH). Syndromes exhibiting overlapping features are often caused by mutations in genes whose products are involved in a common pathway or are integrated in a protein-protein interaction network (concept of molecular disease families). In collaboration with Danny Chan (University of Hong Kong) we have analyzed a knock-in mouse model for BDA1 (Ihh-E95K). We found that, as in the Ror2-W749X mutant, a defect in the elongation of the phalangeal condensations was causative for the brachydactyly phenotype (Gao et al. 2009). Moreover, a similar failure of the BMP/pSMAD1/5/8 signaling center distal to the growing digit was observed (Witte et al. 2010). This leads to the assumption that a) a signaling network converging on BMP/pSMAD1/5/9 signaling is crucial for the elongation of the phalangeal condensations and b) the brachydactyly disease family is caused by perturbation of this network. The individual yet partially overlapping phenotypes of the brachydactyly syndromes hence are explainable by the differential contribution of the affected components of this network to its final outcome, i.e. pSMAD1/5/8-driven chondrogenesis. 

Brachydactyly mutations are found in members of the BMP signaling pathway, in ROR2 and IHH. ROR2 interacts with the WNT and BMP signaling pathways, phenotypic overlap of human syndromes as well as mouse mutants suggests interaction of ROR2 with the IHH pathway as well. From Stricker and Mundlos, Developmental Dynamics 2011, 240(5), 990-1004.

From digit patterning to digit shape

Our appendicular skeleton mainly consists of long bones with exception of the wrist. Directional expansion of long bones is achieved via the so-called growth plate, a structure in which chondrocytes undergo a series of stereotypical differentiation events until they are ultimately replaced by bone. Importantly, in this growth plate chondrocytes in parallel undergo a cellular movement that leads to lateral restriction and concomitant elongation of the anlage in a process similar to convergent extension movements seen in gastrulation. It was noted, that in mice with mutations in the transcription factor HOXD13, which are a model for human Synpolydactyly (SPD), metacarpals ate homeotically transformed to carpal bones (Villavicencio-Lorini et al. J. Clin. Invest. 2010). We have analyzed the molecular mechanism behind this transformation and found that HOXD13 is required for proper spatial induction of the non-canonical WNT ligand WNT5A. This signaling in turn is required for polarization of growth plate and perichondral cells and together confers longitudinal growth to skeletal elements (Kuss et al. Dev. Biol 2014). 

Perichondral signaling is required for bidirectional versus radial growth of cartilage elements; from Kuss et al. 2014.